Welcome to Sergio's Restaurant Zephyrhills
Sergio's Restaurant Zephyrhills is a culinary gem located at 35233 FL-54, Zephyrhills, FL. Renowned for its exceptional pizza, many customers claim it rivals even the best in New York. The menu extends beyond traditional fare, featuring enticing options like the meatball sub and stromboli, which have won hearts for their flavor and convenience. The attentive service, highlighted by staff member Patty, ensures a memorable dining experience. Guests appreciate the warm, inviting atmosphere and the ability to accommodate large parties. With fresh, hot dishes served promptly, Sergio's is a must-visit for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike.
Sergio's Restaurant Zephyrhills: Reviews & Ratings
Number one pizza I've ever had. Even better than a New York Pizza and the meatball sub was phenomenal. I'd like to come back and try other items on the menu. You guys are the best
Being from NY I am very picky when it comes to pizza. Not only was the pizza amazing but the fried mozzarella was delicious as well. The server Patty was very attentive and gave some of the best service I've had in years. I definitely tip my hat to her and will look forward to returning soon!
They're getting very stingy on sausage used to be my favorite pizza place not so sure anymore
We had 9 in our party on a Saturday evening (8 first timers). We showed up without a reservation & had no problem getting seated together. Our server was super nice & knowledgeable about the food & the history. Everyone in our party ordered something different & everyone loved their food. It was all served fresh & hot. I've been looking for a good pizza for a couple years. I think I finally found it the only ding I would give is I prefer some hot garlic bread instead of cold sliced bread.
Been doing takeout pizza for many years but I like the Stromboli better because it is easier for me to eat with my hands
My wife wanted to do Italian last night, 12/5/24, so we googled them and decided on Sergio’s. Our night started out with a 30-40 foot front window just getting finished being airbrushed with a beautiful Christmas scene. We go in, seat ourselves, and are met by one of the best servers we have ever had, Patty! Cheerful, talkative, and just very pleasant! We started out with some wine. We got a carafe of house white, Franzia, and it was huge for 13. Had at least 7-8 six ounce servings. My wife got the Fettuccine Alfredo and it was a whole plate with 3 slices of homemade bread and broccoli cheddar soup. My wife said it was the best Alfredo and soup she has had. 16. Now I got a medium Sergio’s special, about halfway down the pizza menu which is all the toppings of the pizzas above it as a “all the way” or “the works”. I had them change the meatballs to hot jalapenos. It was great, crust, amount of toppings, etc. That was 22, a large is 25. HUGE. For desert we got cannoli’s which were not too sweet, very crispy, just real good. 8. Now Patty came back a lot to check on us and when it was time to leave, she boxed all things left over since I was in a sling from a recent shoulder surgery. The food was hot, came out quick, and really good. Highly recommend and on Thursday-Saturday, ask for Patty.
Foods delicious, ordered take out and it was on time ready and so good. Friendly staff as well’
We love this place. It's been around forever. It's not fancy, but more of a relaxed atmosphere for family and friends. Service is always good and friendly. My husband and I always get the same thing, thin crust Sergio's Special pizza (no onion or green pepper, but extra cheese and tomato). and the crust is so good you never leave any, even the outside pieces. All of the ingredients are fresh, and you can taste it!
Location
-
35233 FL-54, Zephyrhills, FL 33541, United States Hotline: +1 813-788-0432
Welcome to Sergio's Restaurant Zephyrhills, a culinary gem located at 35233 FL-54 in Zephyrhills, Florida. This establishment has quickly carved a niche for itself as a go-to destination for those seeking authentic Italian flavors, particularly renowned for their exceptional pizza and comforting Italian-American dishes. With a simple phone call to +1 813-788-0432, you can embark on a delightful dining experience.
Customers rave about the pizza—a sentiment echoed by John Gedeon, who boldly claims it’s the "number one pizza I've ever had," even surpassing the beloved New York slices. The enthusiasm doesn’t stop there. Don Guerrero, a New Yorker himself, was particularly impressed not only by the pizza but also by the crispy fried mozzarella, and gave a special shoutout to the attentive service provided by Patty, which seems to be a common praise among visitors.
Moreover, Sergio's caters to larger groups, making it an excellent choice for gatherings. Chuck Yosick shared that his party of nine had an effortless experience without a reservation. Each member enjoyed a different dish, highlighting the restaurant’s diverse menu that ensures something for everyone. The fresh, hot offerings were clearly a hit, although some patrons wished for a warmer accompaniment, like garlic bread.
While not every experience is flawless—Nancy Catherine mentioned a perceived cutback on sausage—you can sense an earnest commitment to quality food and service, displayed through a myriad of positive feedback. The Stromboli also receives mention as a favorite uniquely suited for those on the go, like Miriam Seiler.
In summary, Sergio's Restaurant Zephyrhills stands out for its authentic Italian fare, vibrant atmosphere, and dedicated staff. Whether you're a local or visiting Zephyrhills, this hearty establishment is well worth the taste test for any pizza lover or Italian cuisine enthusiast. Prepare yourself for a meal that’s bound to invite you back for more.